October 22, 2012
DiNapoli: Abuse Uncovered at SUNY Research Foundation
Audit Finds Conflicts of Interest, Overpayments, Improper Use of Credit Cards
A wide-ranging audit released today by State Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli uncovered numerous cases of abuse of taxpayer dollars at the SUNY Research Foundation over a number of years. Auditors found improper credit card use, conflicts of interest related to contracts and overpayment of a senior counsel, among other problems.
In light of the findings, DiNapoli announced a new audit of how the Research Foundation charges SUNY campuses for overhead costs, the financial impacts of those charges on the campuses and the administration of overhead dollars administered by the foundation.
"For too long, SUNY Research Foundation employees took advantage of lax oversight to cheat taxpayers, skirt state laws and violate the foundation's own policies," DiNapoli said. "The Research Foundation needs to vastly improve its internal controls, budgetary oversight, and ensure compliance with all relevant laws and policies. The foundation needs to recover all misspent funds immediately and fundamentally change how it operates."
DiNapoli's investigators and auditors found a senior SUNY Research Foundation official at Buffalo State College, Edgar H. Turkle III, used his foundation-provided credit card to personally enrich himself. A review of 424 of Turkle's credit card transactions for the 48-month period November 2007 through November 2011 found 348 purchases totaling $130,887 that were not business-related. Turkle charged the Research Foundation $22,225 for Buffalo Sabres hockey tickets and other personal expenses such as a birthday party for his wife, an Apple computer, iPad and iPhones, chocolates, and groceries. He also traveled to foreign countries, primarily in Asia, in 29 out of the 48 months reviewed, incurring $125,342 in related costs paid through travel vouchers that had no trip itineraries or agendas.
Several of the problems cited took place with the knowledge and understanding of high level officials. Turkle's travel vouchers were approved and processed by employees that Turkle supervised, and not by Turkle's supervisor, while the provost at Buffalo State approved $50,000 in inappropriate extra service payments for Turkle.
Turkle has been terminated by the Research Foundation and the audit's findings have been referred to law enforcement.
Auditors reviewed 13 central office contracts awarded on a sole or single source basis, finding 10 of the contracts, totaling almost $3 million, violated foundation policy.
One contract involved a potential conflict of interest. Michael Barone secured successive extensions of his existing consulting contract with the foundation, through Oct. 31, 2010, as the interim vice president of internal audit. Subsequently, Barone was awarded a new sole source contract with the Research Foundation that added staff from Barone's company, Barone & Associates, to perform further audit services. In total, Barone and his company received $469,700 from December 2009 through May 2011.
Auditors also found:
The Central Office compensated the former general counsel and secretary $345,034, plus a severance package, for less than a year of service. This person was the most highly compensated employee at the Research Foundation for fiscal year 2010-11. DiNapoli's auditors calculated the total cost of hiring and employing this individual was $665,356 for an 11-month period. The general counsel also received a severance package totaling $308,546. This included a payment of $260,000 for one year's salary, $30,000 in accrued vacation leave, and $18,546 in COBRA health insurance benefits through Dec. 31, 2011. It is unclear why the Research Foundation agreed to these payments and other benefits in the employment contract with this person.
In each of these instances, the foundation did not adhere to its policies, which are considerably less stringent than what state agencies and even the State University of New York itself are required to follow.
After conducting fieldwork, auditors also questioned the time and attendance of Research Foundation employee Susan Bruno. Auditors asked the State Attorney General's Office to look into that matter separately.
Auditors also found:
For a copy of the full report, including the foundation's response, visit: http://www.osc.state.ny.us/audits/allaudits/093013/11s24.pdf